Enterprise Networking Planet content and product recommendations are editorially independent. We may make money when you click on links to our partners. Learn More.
Secure Sockets Layer (SSL) and Internet Protocol Security (IPsec) are encryption protocols used to create secure connections over virtual private networks (VPNs).
While both VPN protocols are capable of providing privacy to your online activities, the main difference between the two lies in the way they establish secure connections between a client device and a VPN server.
- SSL VPNs encrypt data at the transport layer and function primarily by encrypting traffic between user devices and web servers.
- IPsec VPNs encrypt and authenticate data at the network layer and can be used to protect data sent over systems with identifiable IP addresses. IPsec VPNs require specific software to be installed.
This guide will dive into the similarities and differences between SSL and IPsec VPNs, and help you choose which is better for your business network.
Table of Contents
SSL vs. IPsec VPN quick comparison
Here’s a comparison table that highlights the core differences between SSL and IPsec VPNs:
| Features | SSL | IPsec |
|---|---|---|
| OSI layer | Application layer | Network layer |
| Configuration | Simple | Complex |
| Implementation | Can be accessed through a web browser and any device with an internet connection | Requires specific client software to be installed |
| Application | Web applications | All network protocols |
| Endpoints | Any device with a web browser | Only approved and configured devices installed with client software |
| Access control | User-based | Device-based |
| Cloud/on-premise | Integrates better with cloud-based applications | Works better with on-premise systems run within an organization’s internal infrastructure |
What are SSL VPNs?
An SSL VPN is a virtual private network that uses the SSL/TLS protocol to create a secure and encrypted connection between a remote user and a private network.
SSL VPNs allow remote users to access private networks from any location as long as they have an internet connection. This makes it possible for employees to work from home or on the go while still having access to their company’s data and resources.
Some of the key benefits of SSL VPNs are that they are easy to set up and use, do not require any special software or hardware installed on the client side, and can be accessed from any web browser. This makes SSL VPNs a popular choice for small to medium-sized businesses that need to provide remote access to their employees but don’t have the resources to set up a dedicated VPN infrastructure on every device within the organization.
Types of SSL VPN
There are two primary options to choose from with an SSL VPN: portal and tunnel.
- Portal: If you’re using a portal SSL VPN, you launch your secure connection via a specific website portal where you enter your credentials. This will often connect you to your enterprise’s home network page, or some other web build that gives you secure access to predefined applications.
- Tunnel: this advancement beyond portal SSL allows users to access non-web applications via the VPN connection.
How SSL VPNs work
SSL VPNs are designed to work like a gateway or entry point to a private network. So when a user attempts to access resources on the network through an SSL VPN, they first establish a connection to the SSL VPN gateway, which is usually a web-based portal that verifies the user’s credentials to determine whether to give the user access.
Depending on the configuration, the SSL VPN can also enforce things like restricting access to certain resources and limiting the type of devices that can connect to the network.
Once the secure connection is established, the user can access resources on the network. The SSL VPN gateway acts as a proxy, encrypting all traffic between the user’s device and the network and decrypting it on the other end.
Pros
- Scalable: SSL VPNs can easily scale to accommodate a growing number of users.
- Easy to use: There’s no need for additional software installation as it can be accessed through a web browser.
- Cost-effective: They’re more budget-friendly since they don’t require dedicated hardware or software.
- Flexibility: They can be accessed from anywhere—and any device—with an internet connection.
Cons
- Latency issues: There’s a possibility of latency issues due to additional processing required for encryption and decryption, leading to delays in data transmission.
- Compatibility issues: SSL VPNs may not work with older or unsupported devices, which can limit their usefulness in certain business environments.
- Network dependency: Poor network availability can prevent users from accessing critical company applications and data.
- Susceptible to attacks: SSL VPNs are comparatively vulnerable to man-in-the-middle attacks.
What are IPsec VPNs?
IPsec VPNs are a set of protocols designed to secure connections between devices at the Internet Protocol (IP) level.
IPsec VPN works by encrypting and authenticating all the data that travels between the devices connected to the VPN, effectively simulating a long-distance LAN. This ensures that the data remains secure and cannot be modified or intercepted by unauthorized parties.
Because IPsec VPNs connect at the IP level, this type of VPN connection makes it possible for IT administrators to see the IP addresses of the devices that access the network.
Types of IPsec VPN
There are two primary options to choose from with an IPSec VPN: transport and tunnel.
- Transport: In this type of IPSec VPN, not all of the data is encrypted; instead, components like the header are transported as is from device to device.
- Tunnel: In this type of IPSec VPN, all of the transmitted data is encrypted, even the headers and titles.
How IPsec VPNs work
IPsec VPNs require specialized hardware and software to be installed on every device before it can connect to the network.
Once the necessary client software is installed in both the sending and receiving devices, it initiates an encryption process using a key exchange between the connected devices. This key exchange allows data to be decrypted by devices connected to the VPN.
Once connection is achieved, data is transmitted in small packets through the network using a transport protocol. This data passes through an authentication process to ensure it comes from a trusted source.
Pros
- Full access: Provides full access to other devices on the network, instead of just to a single application or utility.
- Security: Ensures high-level security protocols since it requires you to install the correct client software.
- Authentication: Provides strong authentication through digital certificates, pre-shared keys, or other methods.
Cons
- Complexity: These VPNs require experienced network engineers to set up and run them.
- Lack of flexibility: If a user’s IPsec-enabled device develops a fault, the user may be cut off from the VPN, creating bottlenecks.
- Expensive: The additional hardware, software, and ongoing maintenance can become costly for organizations.
Who should use IPSec VPNs and SSL VPNs?
IPsec and SSL VPNs are both good options for establishing secure virtual private networks in organizations. The choice of which one to adopt depends on factors such as the organization’s security requirements, the type of applications it uses, and the level of control it wants over its remote access infrastructure.
When to use IPSec VPNs
IPSec VPNs are a good choice for organizations requiring high-end security and more complex network infrastructure.
They are best suited for organizations that need to connect two or more networks securely, as they offer site-to-site connectivity.
They are also a good fit for organizations that need to ensure their data’s confidentiality, integrity, and authenticity, as IPSec VPNs provide end-to-end encryption and strong authentication algorithms.
When to use SSL VPNs
SSL VPNs are good for organizations that need to provide secure remote access to individual users or devices, such as telecommuters, contractors, or mobile workers.
SSL VPNs are easier to set up and manage than IPSec VPNs, and they work well for organizations that need to provide remote access to web-based applications.
SSL VPNs also provide access controls that can be used to restrict users’ access to specific resources, such as applications or data.
Bottom line: SSL and IPsec VPNs
Both IPSec VPNs and SSL VPNs are excellent choices for organizations that need secure remote access. The choice between the two depends on several factors, including the organization’s security requirements, the type of applications your organization uses, and the level of control it wants over its remote access infrastructure.
Larger organizations—or those in highly regulated industries—with dedicated network administration teams, and those looking to securely connect two or more networks, may want to invest in an IPsec VPN.
Meanwhile, smaller companies or those with a highly dispersed workforce that are seeking a reliable, secure connection to proprietary apps and data might be better served with an SSL VPN.
Ultimately, the choice between IPsec VPNs and SSL VPNs will be based on the organization’s specific needs, resources, and objectives.
We reviewed the best VPN services to keep your networks and data secure.
